The county auditor could not review the security of the vote-counting software. Here is what the audit says, and the Clerk's reasons

Local news and government watch for Bend and Central Oregon. Also on Reddit at u/bend_oregon-news.

Disclosure: I'm Jonathan Curtis, a candidate for Deschutes County Clerk on the Nov 3 ballot. Everything below comes from the county's own reports linked at the bottom. Corrections welcome, and I'll post them here.

The good news first. The County's 2025 elections audit of the Clerk's Office (A0129, updated Nov. 2025) set out to decide whether the election system is secure, accessible and accurate. It found controls were working as intended overall.

The gap. The audit says the Clerk "refused to provide auditors with information about information security related to ballot counting software" (the Clear Ballot system). The list of items the audit says it asked for includes the security plan, IT security procedures, staff training records and a review of the system's components. As a result, the auditor says it "cannot draw a conclusion" about information security for that software.

The Clerk's stated reason. In the Clerk's written response, the office says it is required by state law, administrative rule and Secretary of State Critical Directive 2022-3 to keep the Election Security Plan confidential. It says the Clerk decided, after consulting the Secretary of State's elections division, county legal counsel, other county clerks and the Oregon Association of County Clerks, to keep the plan from the auditor's process, and that the decision was shared by county clerks throughout Oregon. The Clerk's response also says the office was fully transparent about everything else the auditor asked for.

The auditor's reply. The audit says ORS 254.074 requires filing security plans with the Secretary of State and exempts them from public records requests, but "audit requests are not public records requests," and that County code gives the auditor unrestricted access to information and records. It also says it found no additional legal justification for the refusal.

Status. The audit made 2 recommendations; per the county page, 0 are resolved and 2 are in process, with follow-up reports scheduled for 2026.

Both sides are on the record. I'd ask the Clerk's Office and the auditor to publish how a confidential security review could be done without exposing the plan.

Sources:

Posted by Jonathan Curtis, Bend. Corrections welcome and will be posted here.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

I'm Jonathan Curtis. Here's Who I Am, in My Own Words.

A Letter About Home

Nine Kids, One Family